Pengadilan Niaga pada PN Jakarta Pusat menolak gugatan TikTok Ltd yang meminta merek “Tik Tok” milik pengusaha pakaian asal Bandung, Fenfiana Saputra, dihapus dari Daftar Umum Merek. Majelis menilai merek di kelas 25 (pakaian) itu terbukti masih dipakai berdagang, sehingga dalil tidak digunakan selama lima tahun berturut-turut tidak terbukti.
The Facts of the Case
TikTok Ltd, a company incorporated in the Cayman Islands, has filed a lawsuit against Fenfiana Saputra and the Ministry of Law and Human Rights in the Commercial Court of the Central Jakarta District Court. The lawsuit was filed under case number 79/Pdt.Sus-HKI/Merek/2024/PN Niaga Jkt.Pst on August 12, 2024, and was decided on January 20, 2025, by a panel of judges presided over by Buyung Dwikora, with Haryuning Respati and Budi Prayitno serving as members.
The subject of the dispute is the “Tik Tok” trademark owned by Fenfiana, registered on February 19, 2009, in Class 25 for infant, children’s, and adult clothing, with registration number IDM000193975. TikTok Ltd itself holds registered trademarks in classes 6, 9, 16, 18, 35, and 42, but not in the clothing class.
In its complaint, TikTok Ltd. requested that the defendant’s trademark be removed from the General Trademark Register because it had not been used in commerce for five consecutive years. TikTok stated that it had a legal interest in this matter, namely to obtain exclusive rights to its own goods and services. Fenfiana’s trademark registration is said to be obstructing TikTok’s application for the clothing class.
The court dismissed the lawsuit and ordered TikTok Ltd. to pay court costs of Rp1,580,000.
Why was the lawsuit dismissed?
The lawsuit was filed under the mechanism for the cancellation of trademarks due to non-use (Article 74 of Law No. 20 of 2016). The deadline was originally three years, but was extended to five consecutive years by Constitutional Court Decision No. 144/PUU-XXI/2023.
The issue is not who is more famous, but whether the brand is actually being used. Fenfiana presented “Tik Tok”-branded clothing that is still being produced by CV Indomas Triputra Garment in Bandung, along with evidence of shipments and sales from 2017 to 2024. The court ruled that the brand has been proven to be used on baby clothing products that are still being sold today, thus the argument that it had not been used for five years was not substantiated. The plaintiff’s argument regarding products lacking SNI certification was deemed irrelevant.
During the trial, Fenfiana stated that the brand belonged to her father and had been in use since around 2001 or 2002.
How is that possible: a global reputation doesn’t automatically guarantee success
Indonesia follows a “first-to-file” system: trademark rights arise upon registration, not through fame. The Fenfiana trademark was registered first, whereas TikTok Ltd. was only established in 2016 and entered the Indonesian market in 2018. Trademark protection is also limited to the classes of goods and services for which the trademark is registered. The plaintiff’s “TikTok” trademark is registered in six classes, but not in Class 25.
This ruling is narrow in scope. The court did not evaluate the TikTok trademark for video apps; it merely held that Fenfiana retains the rights to the “Tik Tok” trademark in the clothing class, meaning that TikTok Ltd cannot claim it for that class in Indonesia.
Lessons for Business Owners
Register your trademark early, because the first to register receives stronger protection.
Keep records of ongoing operations: production records, shipping documents, and sales records. In this case, it was those records that saved the brand.
Owners of major brands need to check for registered trademarks in each class they intend to enter before expanding their business.
Case Status
So far, only the first-instance ruling has been reported, and TikTok Ltd. may still pursue legal remedies. As of November 18, 2026, there has been no information regarding an appeal or an official response from TikTok Ltd. or Fenfiana.
Before publication, there are three things you should check because my source is only news reports, not a copy of the ruling: the case number and the ruling in the Central Jakarta District Court’s SIPP system or the Supreme Court’s Ruling Directory; the spelling of the judge’s name (which varies across media outlets); and Fenfiana’s statement regarding the origin of the brand, which I found in only one media outlet.
This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The analysis is based on news reports and publicly available information at the time of writing, rather than on a complete copy of the ruling, and therefore may differ from the content of the official ruling.